Best Mascaras from Top Stores

Updated October 11, 2026

Compare the best mascaras from top stores in one place.

Mascara prices on this page run from about $28 to $61. Options include waterproof, volumizing, lengthening, and tubular formulas with a variety of brush shapes.

A curved brush can lift lashes, while a dense wand adds volume. Waterproof formulas stay put in humidity but may need an oil-based remover. Look for ingredients like conditioning oils if you have fragile lashes.

When selecting, consider the finish you want-dramatic black, natural brown, or a tinted shade-and whether you need a primer or a dual-ended product for flexibility.

Questions

Is waterproof mascara good for daily wear?

It lasts longer in moisture but can be harder to remove, so use a gentle remover if you wear it every day.

What brush type gives the most volume?

A thick, dense brush or a tubular wand deposits more product on each lash for a fuller look.

Can I layer different mascaras?

Yes, you can apply a lengthening formula first and then a volumizing one for a combined effect.

Will mascara damage my lashes?

Using a clean brush and removing mascara gently reduces the risk of breakage.