Best Mascaras from Top Stores

Shop Nobi guide Updated October 30, 2026

Best Mascaras from Top Stores Mascara on this page runs from about $28 to $61.

Best Mascaras from Top Stores Most formulas are described as volumizing, lengthening, waterproof or tubing, and many mention a specific brush shape such as curved or tubular.

Best Mascaras from Top Stores When choosing a mascara look for the finish you prefer, dramatic volume, length, or a natural look, and check if the brush will reach every lash.

Best Mascaras from Top Stores Waterproof options are good for long wear or humid weather, while non-waterproof formulas are easier to remove.

Relevée Mascara

Bluemercury $36.00 See it at the store

FetishEyes Mascara

Bluemercury $34.00 See it at the store

Lash Doubling Mascara

Bluemercury $28.00 See it at the store

How often should I replace my mascara?

Most experts recommend replacing mascara every three to six months to avoid bacterial buildup.

Best Mascaras from Top Stores The full page has every pick, the whole guide and more questions. See every pick