Cookie Sheets: Compare Listings & Prices
Catalog refreshed October 17, 2026
Content revised October 28, 2026
Browse 12 listings for Cookie Sheets, including options from Kitchen Kapers and Camden Rose. Compare product details and listed prices.
The 12 displayed listings with prices are listed from $16.50 to $35.00 (USD) in this catalog snapshot. Confirm the selected variant's current price, availability and purchase terms with the retailer.
Most are aluminum with a non-stick coating, while a few are wooden or feature insulated layers for even baking. Standard half-sheet sizes (18"×13") are common, and some sheets have a raised grid for airflow.
When selecting a sheet, check the coating: a durable non-stick surface makes release easy, but a silicone mat can be a reusable alternative. Aluminum sheets conduct heat quickly, which helps cookies spread evenly. Insulated sheets reduce hot spots for more uniform browning.
Look for reinforced rims to prevent warping, and consider whether you need a sheet with a built-in grid for extra crispness. Wooden sheets are decorative and can double as serving trays, but they require careful cleaning.

Nordicware Naturals® Large Classic Cookie Sheet
Kitchen Kapers
$19.99

Wooden Cookie Sheet - With or Without Wooden or Felt Cookie Sets
Camden Rose
$16.50

Mrs. Anderson's Baking Half Sheet Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$19.99

Nordic Ware Naturals Sheet Pan with Oven-Safe Nonstick Grid
Kitchen Kapers
$34.95

Nordic Ware Naturals Insulated Baking Sheet
Kitchen Kapers
$34.95

Mrs. Anderson's Baking Heavyweight Quarter Sheet Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$16.99

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Nonstick Large Jelly Roll Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$31.95

Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$24.95

Mrs. Anderson's Baking Jelly Roll Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$19.99

Nordic Ware Naturals Half & Quarter Sheet Pan Set
Kitchen Kapers
$29.95

Mrs. Anderson's 16" X 22" Full Oven Sheet Pan
Kitchen Kapers
$24.99

Little Sheet
Great Jones
$35.00
Questions
What is the best material for a cookie sheet?
Aluminum with a non-stick coating is popular for even heat distribution and easy release.
Can I use a wooden cookie sheet in the oven?
Wooden sheets are usually meant for serving and should not be used at high baking temperatures.
Do insulated cookie sheets bake better?
Insulated sheets reduce hot spots, helping cookies bake more evenly.
How do I prevent my cookie sheet from warping?
Choose a sheet with a reinforced rim and avoid sudden temperature changes.
Is a silicone baking mat better than a non-stick sheet?
Silicone mats are reusable and provide a non-stick surface, but they may not brown the bottom as much as a metal sheet.