Cookie Cutters: Compare Listings & Prices
Catalog refreshed October 17, 2026
Content revised October 28, 2026
Browse 20 listings for Cookie Cutters, including options from House of Staunton and Kitchen Kapers. Compare product details and listed prices.
The 20 displayed listings with prices are listed from $0.60 to $24.95 (USD) in this catalog snapshot. Confirm the selected variant's current price, availability and purchase terms with the retailer.
They come in themed shapes like Halloween, Hanukkah, and animal designs, and are offered in sets of three or as single pieces. Most are made from polyresin or metal, giving a sturdy edge for clean cuts.
When picking cutters, consider the size of the cookie you want to make and the material, metal cutters stay sharper longer, while resin is lighter and often cheaper. Look for smooth edges and a comfortable handle if the cutter is large. Sets give variety, but single-piece cutters are useful for a specific design you’ll use often.
Cleaning is easy for most cutters; many are dishwasher safe, but hand washing can preserve the finish. Store them in a drawer or a dedicated holder to keep the shapes from bending.

Chess Themed Cookie Cutters
House of Staunton
$11.95

R & M Set of 6 Mini Halloween Cookie Cutters
Kitchen Kapers
$9.99

Zion Judaica Set of 5 Hanukkah Cookie Cutters
Kitchen Kapers
$4.99

OXO Double-Sided Cookie and Biscuit Cutter Set
Kitchen Kapers
$24.95

Geometric Cookie Cutter, Set of 3
Hawkins New York
$12.00

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- White Snowflake
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

Fox Run 3" Horse Head Cookie Cutter
Kitchen Kapers
$0.60

Nostalgia Cookie Cutter, Set of 3
Hawkins New York
$12.00

Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- White Cross
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Star
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Red Candy Cane
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

Snowflake Cookie Cutter, Set of 3
Hawkins New York
$12.00

Ornament Cookie Cutter, Set of 3
Hawkins New York
$12.00

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Turkey
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Snowman with Top Hat
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Tree with Star
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- White Easter Egg
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter - Orange Pumpkin
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- White Dog Bone
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99

R & M Polyresin Coated Cookie Cutter- Number One
Kitchen Kapers
$3.99
Questions
Can I use metal cookie cutters for dough that’s very soft?
Yes, metal cutters work well with soft dough and hold their shape better than plastic.
Are polyresin cutters dishwasher safe?
Most polyresin cutters are safe in the dishwasher, but check the product details to be sure.
How do I keep the cutter edges sharp?
Wash and dry the cutter promptly and avoid using it on hard surfaces that could dull the edge.
Do I need a special storage container?
A simple drawer or a dedicated cutter holder keeps the shapes from bending and makes them easy to find.