Pacifiers: Compare Listings & Prices
Updated October 19, 2026
Browse 20 listings for Pacifiers, including options from Luggage Online and mushie. Compare product details and listed prices.
The 20 displayed listings with prices are listed from $11.49 to $34.99 (USD) in this catalog snapshot. Confirm the selected variant's current price, availability and purchase terms with the retailer.
They are sold in packs of two, four, or six and come in silicone or natural rubber, with designs ranging from simple shapes to decorative patterns.
Silicone pacifiers are soft, flexible, and easy to clean, while natural rubber offers a more traditional feel. Many models are orthodontic, featuring a symmetrical shape that supports healthy oral development.
When selecting a pacifier, consider the material that best suits your baby’s sensitivity, the size appropriate for their age, and a design that stays securely in the mouth. Look for BPA-free certification and a sturdy shield to prevent choking.

J.L. Childress Pacifier Pal Pacifier Pocket and Toy, Fits 2-3 Pacifiers
Luggage Online
$11.49
We may earn a commission

FRIGG Daisy Night Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Daisy Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Daisy Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Daisy Night Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifier 4-Pack
mushie
$24.99

FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifier 6-Pack
mushie
$34.99

FRIGG Silicone Pacifier 4-Pack
mushie
$24.99

FRIGG Silicone Pacifier 6-Pack
mushie
$34.99

FRIGG Lucky Symmetrical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack (0-6 Months)
mushie
$16.99

FRIGG Butterfly Anatomical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack (0-6 Months)
mushie
$16.99

FRIGG Butterfly Anatomical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack (6-18 Months)
mushie
$16.99

FRIGG Lucky Symmetrical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack (6-18 Months)
mushie
$16.99

FRIGG Moon Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier Moonlight Sailing (Cream) 4-Pack
mushie
$19.99

FRIGG Moon Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier Moonlight Sailing (Powder Blue) 4-Pack
mushie
$19.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier Floral Heart (Blush) 4-Pack
mushie
$19.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier Floral Heart (Cream) 4-Pack
mushie
$19.99

FRIGG Andersen Fairytale Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack
mushie
$14.99
Questions
Are silicone pacifiers better than rubber?
Silicone is hypoallergenic and easy to clean, while rubber feels more natural; both are safe if BPA-free.
What size pacifier should I buy for a 4-month-old?
Choose a pacifier labeled for 0-6 months, which fits most infants in that age range.
How often should I replace a pacifier?
Replace it when it shows signs of wear, tears, or after about three months of regular use.