Best Ice Cube Trays from Top Stores

Updated October 11, 2026

Compare the best ice cube trays from top stores in one place.

Ice cube trays on this page range from about $9.99 to $34.95. Most are made of flexible silicone or sturdy plastic, and a few use stainless-steel frames for extra durability.

Look for a size that fits your freezer and the type of ice you need, larger cubes for drinks, smaller ones for cocktails. Spill-proof designs with lids or raised edges help keep water from leaking while filling.

Silicone trays release cubes easily and are dishwasher safe, while metal or rigid plastic trays tend to last longer but may need a bit more effort to pop the cubes out.

Questions

What size ice cubes are best for cocktails?

Smaller, square or sphere-shaped cubes melt slower and keep drinks cold without diluting them quickly.

Are silicone trays safe for the freezer?

Yes, food-grade silicone can handle freezer temperatures and is easy to clean.

Do lids on ice trays prevent freezer odors?

Lids help keep the tray sealed, reducing odor transfer and preventing spills.