Best Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt from Top Stores

Updated October 11, 2026

Compare the best ice cream and frozen yogurt from top stores in one place.

Ice cream and frozen yogurt on this page range from about $4.99 to $89. Most items are dairy-free, fruit-based sherbets, classic vanilla or chocolate flavors, and creative mixes like sweet potato marshmallow or pear and blue cheese.

When choosing, consider whether you want dairy or dairy-free options, the level of sweetness, and any mix-ins such as cookies or fruit. Look for clear ingredient lists if you have dietary restrictions.

Texture varies from smooth custard style to airy sherbet; higher priced tubs often include premium ingredients or larger quantities. Decide on portion size and flavor profile that fits your taste.

Questions

How can I tell if an ice cream is dairy-free?

Look for dairy-free labeling or check the ingredient list for plant milks such as almond, oat or coconut.

What’s the difference between sherbet and ice cream?

Sherbet contains fruit juice and less milk fat, giving a lighter texture, while ice cream has more cream for a richer mouthfeel.

Can I store these frozen desserts for a long time?

They can be kept in the freezer for several weeks, but for best texture use them within a month of purchase.

Are there any common allergens in these products?

Many flavors include nuts, dairy or gluten, so read the ingredient list if you have sensitivities.