Best Tomatoes from Top Stores

Updated October 11, 2026

Compare the best tomatoes from top stores in one place, juicy varieties for any dish.

Tomatoes on this page run from about $4.95 to $59.95. You’ll find common varieties like beefsteak and heirloom as well as specialty types such as San Marzano, organic and pink-hued tomatoes.

Look for size and flesh type that suit your cooking, larger beefsteak tomatoes are great for slicing, while smaller heirloom or cherry-style fruits add flavor to salads. Check whether the label mentions organic or non-GMO if that matters to you.

Consider the intended use: sauces benefit from dense, low-water varieties, whereas fresh eating prefers sweet, juicy types. Freshness is often indicated by bright color and firm skin.

Questions

How do I store fresh tomatoes?

Keep them at room temperature away from direct sunlight and use them within a few days for best flavor.

Are organic tomatoes more expensive?

Organic varieties often cost more because of the farming practices required.

Can I freeze tomatoes for later use?

Yes, blanch and peel them before freezing for sauces or soups.