Best Peppers from Top Stores

Updated October 11, 2026

Compare the best peppers from top stores in one place, colorful crunch for cooking.

Peppers on this page vary from $3.95 for a small fish hot pepper to $39.95 for specialty varieties like Jungle Parrot and Costa Rican Sweet. The list includes hot, sweet and mild peppers in colors ranging from green to red and orange.

When picking peppers, note the heat level indicated by the name, hot peppers are spicier than sweet ones. Look for firm skins, bright colors and no soft spots. Larger sweet peppers are great for stuffing, while smaller hot peppers work well in sauces.

Store fresh peppers in the refrigerator’s crisper drawer to keep them crisp for up to a week. They can be roasted, grilled, pickled or used raw in salads.

Questions

How can I tell how spicy a pepper is?

Heat is measured in Scoville units; hot peppers have higher numbers than sweet varieties.

Can I freeze fresh peppers?

Yes, slice or chop them and freeze in airtight bags for later use.

Do the colors of peppers indicate flavor?

Color often reflects maturity, but flavor depends on the specific variety.

What’s the best way to store peppers to stay fresh?

Keep them in a plastic bag in the refrigerator’s crisper drawer.

Are sweet peppers safe for people who avoid spice?

Sweet peppers contain little to no capsaicin, so they are mild and suitable for most diets.