Best Nut Butters from Top Stores

Shop Nobi guide Updated October 22, 2026

Best Nut Butters from Top Stores Nut butters on this page range from about $6 to $40.

Best Nut Butters from Top Stores The selection includes single-nut varieties like pistachio, almond, cashew and hazelnut, as well as mixed-nut blends and flavored spreads such as vanilla caramel, chai spice and blueberry-chia.

Best Nut Butters from Top Stores Most products are roasted nuts ground into a smooth paste, and many add extra ingredients like chocolate, sea salt, fruit or spices for extra flavor.

Best Nut Butters from Top Stores Look for clear labeling of the nut base, any added sweeteners, and whether the butter is raw or roasted, as this affects taste and nutrition.

Mixed Nut Butter - 10oz Container

Fastachi $32.00 See it at the store

Koeze Cream-Nut Peanut Butter (Assorted Flavors)

Harney and Sons $8.50 See it at the store

Roasted Pistachio Butter - 10oz Container

Fastachi $40.00 See it at the store

Are nut butters usually safe for people with nut allergies?

Only the specific nut listed is safe; anyone allergic to that nut should avoid the product.

Best Nut Butters from Top Stores The full page has every pick, the whole guide and more questions. See every pick