Best Eyeliners from Top Stores

Shop Nobi guide Updated October 30, 2026

Best Eyeliners from Top Stores Eyeliners on this page range from about $13 to $85. The names show pencil, gel, liquid, waterproof and tightline formats, so you have many formula choices.

Best Eyeliners from Top Stores When picking, think about how you like to apply: pencils are easy for quick lines, gels give a smooth, long-lasting finish, and liquids provide the sharpest precision.

Best Eyeliners from Top Stores Waterproof options are best for humid days or long wear.

Best Eyeliners from Top Stores Check each brand’s shade description and whether the product is labeled waterproof or smudge-proof. Also note any special claims like “tightline” that target the waterline area.

In Perspective Eyeliner Pencil

Bluemercury $33.00 See it at the store

Gel Eyeliner

Bluemercury $51.00 See it at the store

Dawn to Dusk Gel Eyeliner

Bluemercury $26.00 See it at the store

What eyeliner formulas are listed?

The list includes pencil, gel, liquid, waterproof gel, tightline and powder-type formulas.

Best Eyeliners from Top Stores The full page has every pick, the whole guide and more questions. See every pick